The film adaptation of the novel by Gabriel Garcia Marquez and starring Javier Bardem, Benjamin Bratt and Giovanna Mezzogiorno turns out to be overfull with love, and could have done with a great deal more cholera. Shambling and rambling this tale spanning five decades concerns the interwoven lives of three people in a nameless Latin American country. Poor telegraph boy Florentino falls desperately in love with wealthy Fermina, much to the disappointment of her father who sends her off into the jungle to forget. Upon her return she dumps the poor Florentino and marries instead urbane, devastatingly handsome and successful Doctor Urbino. Florentino vows to stay faithful to Fermina and keep himself until he can marry her. He does this by bedding several hundred women - a surprising feat considering his lack of looks, and increasing age - all due to the fact that he claims his heart is waiting to be filled with love and he represents no threat to the women. There are several problems with this film - all the actors talk with heavy Latin accents (I wonder why they didn't let them speak in their own language and use subtitles - fear of commercial failure perhaps?); the second difficulty is the lack of clear identification of the peripheral characters - it is never clear whether these are relatives, friends, acquaintances or (seemingly nameless) passers by. Then there is the problem of aging. The opening scene the three main characters in their seventies proves that a bit of make up and stooping isn't really convincing. These are clearly youthful actors. The story is only just this side of credible, and regularly strays into soft porn. Is this the fault of the book or the film. A pity, because much more could have been made from the basic premise. Rating - 5/10
Monday, 31 March 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
I went to see the film last week and I enjoyed it, but I agree with your cricitisms. Florentino aged a lot more than Fermina and when they were together at the end they just looked odd together. I was really disappointed that it was not in Spanish and seeing as this is a well known and popular book, I still think in Spanish it would be a commercial success.
Yes - I hope it would have been a success in Spanish - there are so many good Spanish films about, but in the UK there is resistance from audiences who HAVE to READ subtitles - too much like hard work!
Thanks for commenting on my blog. My blog is about my life and my knitting, so different from yours.
I found your blog because I think you also got a message in Portuguese recently, and when I checked out your blog I was interested in what you were saying.
I'll keep reading your reviews and commenting on my thoughts.
At the moment I want to see The Orphanage because I am a fan of Guillermo del Toro. I'll keep checking if you do a review on it.
I'm not sure (looking at the trailers) that The Orphanage is my taste - far too scary for me! But we'll see - if I run out of my usual films I will try and catch it - in daylight only!
Post a Comment